August 30, 2009 at Saint Mark Church in Norman, OK
Deuteronomy 4: 1-2,6-8 + Psalm 15 + James 1: 17-18,21-22,27 + Mark 7:1-8,14-15,21-23
As I was sitting with this Gospel, began to remember an old saying my father used to use on me and my sister. We have been collecting some of those old sayings our parents used on us now and then and this one came to mind: “Sticks and Stone will break your bones, but words can never hurt you.” Now several of those old sayings are going to be the subject of a long conversation one of these days when we meet again in the Kingdom: that is provided their plans for me to get there are realized! What in the world was my dad thinking? The person who first said that must have been a deaf-mute! Words hurt, and they hurt a lot longer than sticks and stones, at least that’s my experience. Yet Words are important so they must be chosen carefully. The Jewish people often referred to the Ten Commandments as the “Ten Words.” Insisting that those words have power, the power to save or the power to justify.
This is the heart of the dispute with Jesus. He is suggesting something else. He challenges the idea that just keeping the rules or minding the commandments is not enough. In fact, that behavior can sometimes lead to evil, wrongdoing, and take one far away from God. Jesus makes a contrast between what is inside and what is outside.
He suggests that it is what is within us that matters first and foremost and paying attention to that – perhaps we could call it, that inner voice is motive for and the source of goodness and righteousness.
There are times when strict adherence to the law can produce the opposite of what is intended. Rather than enhance human life and direct us to God, rigid conformity can restrict life and result in smug self-satisfaction. In his example of life, he makes exceptions when the good of others seems to call for exceptions. What we enter into with this passage from Mark’s Gospel is probably a look at the early church and an inner-Jewish dispute. The Pharisees were primarily a lay group dedicated to strict observance of the Temple regulations for purity in their daily lives as a sign that every aspect of life could be holy. What we might suspect is that the followers of Christ were beginning to struggle among themselves over how to keep the law and yet be faithful to the master’s vision of the family of God hospitable to all, welcoming the increasing number of Gentiles and Greeks who were not “clean.”
In this Gospel Jesus speaks not to the Pharisees and scribes, but to his disciples, warning them of those evils that can pollute the human heart and destroy relationships. It strikes me that this struggle is always with us. We face it as a nation when we struggle over the law and the immigrants – over whether or not the demands of charity that are rooted in our hearts might influence the imposition of the law and how we might view the law when we see it tear families apart with children left helpless and homeless while we enforce the law. This is just the most obvious example of what this Gospel suggests we might need to consider on an even larger scale.
A lot of human suffering and destruction goes on in every age as people hide behind rules and regulations. Jesus is concerned about moral defilement and how it comes into the world. He shows us that it happens in the exact opposite way of ritual impurity. Defilement begins and develops in the human heart in the cultivation of evil thoughts, intentions, and imaginings.
We all work from the inside out, not the other way around. If our minds are full of fornication, theft, murder, adultery, avarice, wickedness, jealousy, deceit, slander and pride, these drive our actions. Hiding behind the facade of keeping all the rules does not build a kingdom of love and peace. The Pharisees and scribes are obsessed with the ritual defilement and the external world. Jesus is attentive on the internal world and the moral havoc it releases. He insists that we pay attention to and focus on what drives moral behavior.
There is always more going on within us than we care to admit. Without attending to the inner voice and the inner self, the outer easily turns into an act into hypocrisy. This is the beginning of shallow trivial lives concerned about how things look more than with how things really are. Jesus lives out of his heart and proposes that those who would follow him would confront any inability to hold together the inner love of God and neighbor and the outer ways hat love should be embodied.