October 28, 2007 at Saint Mark Church in Norman, OK
Sirach 35:12-13,16-18 + Psalm 34 + 2 Timothy 4:6-8,16-18 + Luke 18:9-14
This parable brings to a close the Journey to Jerusalem. One more time, Luke uses to very opposite characters to pull a reversal. One of these men has every right and reason to be there. The other because of his frequent contact with Romans and Gentiles ought not be there because of his uncleanness. None the less, there they are one in the front, one in the back. By now, we should not be surprised by the reversals so common in Luke’s Gospel!
The prayer of the Pharisee seems to be addressing God, but he’s really talking to himself. The pronoun “I” is repeated four times! He is the center of his prayer. He is more interested in the tax collector in back than in God. In contrast, just as with last week’s Judge and Widow, there in the back is the Pharisee’s opposite. He takes no note of anyone else, and his prayer acknowledges only a merciful God and his own unworthiness.
Now remember, the culture who first heard this parable would have totally identified with the good, pious, law-abiding Pharisee. For those first listeners, this is a stunning reversal as Jesus concludes the story scorning the good guy and praising the bad guy. This story turns everything upside down.
But maybe there is more here than we know. Just suppose on the way to the Temple that morning the Pharisee took groceries to a family where no one had a job, stopped to see someone recently left alone by the death of a spouse, and picked up a street person and took them to a shelter, leaving some cash to help feed them. Suppose at the same time,
the Publican on his way to the temple evicted a single parent from some of his rental property because they were late on rent, had a huge breakfast and left no tip after being rude and demanding to the server,
and on the way into the Temple dropped in only some loose change from his pocket at the offering plate.
With these considerations first impressions begin to fail, as well they should. The issue here is the comparison. This is that trap in the story that catches us by surprise and teaches us a lesson. It was a surprise for those who first heard this story from Jesus too. A surprise twist leaves us thinking
and that is the whole point of parable telling.
Where the prayer of the Pharisee goes wrong is not in thanking God or acknowledging what he has become by God’s grace; but in comparing himself to another. It is the word: “Like” that betrays something out of order. With that word, he crosses the line from gratitude to comparison. It is a subtle difference, but we know how it feels.
Suppose we could listen in to the prayers of some who are here this morning: “Thank God I am not like that one over there who sings off key.”
“Thank God I am not like that liberal who is destroying the church.” “Thank God I am not like those lazy people on welfare stealing my reluctant tax money.” You see, it is just like the Temple scene, For all his faults, the Publican at least has the integrity to look only at himself. He knew who he was. He never said, “I’m sorry I am not as good as or “like” the Pharisee.
It does not matter how we compare in the end. What matters is that we know ourselves and who we really are within. Because it is God who saves, and God is after us all. The Publican went home “justified.” Not because he went to the Temple, not because his prayer was better than someone else’s. He went home justified because he knew that he could not justify himself, and he was honest about his imperfect self. We have no idea where the Pharisee went. Perhaps he went on trying to justify himself or impress God further by other good deeds so that God might not let anything bad happen to him. That’s the way it often goes with that kind of prayer and attitude — a sort “Divine Bribery” that will see faith and prayer collapse if some tragedy occurs. They think, after all, “I’ve been so good. I’ve done so much. How could God do this to me?” Wrong thinking here. Jesus might well have had the same thoughts if His prayer and relationship to God had gone that way.
Our clue to the understanding of this parable comes in the First reading from Sirach. “The Lord is a God of justice, who knows no favorites……..
Who we are in the sight of God has nothing to do with anyone else.
God cannot, will not, and does compare us to one another.
But God will look for signs of His Son in us.